Wednesday, May 15, 2019

Felix Manz: The Battle over Baptism


Image result for felix manz
                                                            (Felix Manz 1498-1527)

When protestants reflect on the Reformation, we usually focus only on the hero moments—like Martin Luther boldly nailing his “95 Theses” to the church door in Wittenburg or William Tyndale’s battles against the bishops to get the Bible translated into a common tongue.

However, there is a dark side to the Reformation that is seldom talked about. Some of the Reformers persecuted other Christians. Such is the case with the Anabaptists, who emerged out of Zurich, Switzerland. One of the leading reformers in Zurich was a man named Huldrych Zwingli. Like Luther, Zwingli had serious beef with the erroneous teachings of the Catholic Church. In fact, Zwingli published his own diatribe against the Pope listing 67 points of contention. Zwingli’s fame quickly spread, and he attracted other young men who believed as he did that the Gospel had to be rescued from the clutches of the corrupt Catholic Church.

One of Zwingli’s disciples was a youthful and zealous student named Felix Manz. However, after a few years their relationship began to sour over a doctrinal disagreement about infant baptism. Infant baptism had been practiced in Christendom for over a thousand-years by this time and Zwingli still supported it as a viable sacrament. However, Felix Manz along with a few other disciples of Zwingli could not find infant baptism anywhere in the Scriptures.

So on January 21, 1525 Felix Manz and a dozen others decided to form their own sect by baptizing one another as adults. They called themselves “Anabaptists” which means, “rebaptizers” since they argued that believers baptism must come after repentance and a profession of faith in Christ.  They saw infants as incapable of these spiritual conditions, thus the need to be baptized again. The Anabaptists insisted that a child could not be made a Christian even if an ocean of water were poured over his or her head.  

Felix Manz and his friends were ordered by Zwingli and the city council to recant and practice only infant baptism. Manz refused and was soon arrested. On January 5, 1527 Felix was led from prison to a boat in the Limmat River. On the way he gave praises to God and preached to the people gathered to watch him die. One of Zwingli’s priests went along, still trying to convert him. Manz's brother and mother were there as well, urging him to stand fast for the faith.

Image result for felix manz

                                                          (The Execution of Felix Manz)

With hands and feet bound, Manz was taken to the middle of the river and thrown in. Eyewitnesses say he was neither fearful nor despairing. His last words were, “Father, into your hands, O Lord, I commend my spirit.” As for Zwingli, it is said he was on the shore, and with more than a touch of sarcasm said, “If he wishes to go under the water, let him go under.” In other words, if Manz wants to be baptized, let us baptize him by drowning!

Manz was not the only “radical reformer” persecuted by his own during this time. Historians tell us that more Anabaptists were martyred after the Reformation that Christians who died in the early persecutions of Rome![1] The sacrifice of men like Manz and other Anabaptists highlights the Church’s long and bloody struggle for doctrinal purity.

The Bible is abundantly clear of what baptism is, who it is for, and what it accomplishes. In the New Testament, only believers who had placed their faith in Christ were baptized - as a public testimony of their faith and identification with Him (Acts 2:38; Rom. 6:3-4). An infant cannot place his or her faith in Christ, nor can they understand the symbolism. Moreover, the Bible does not record any infants being baptized. At the same time, baptism does not produce salvation. Only faith alone in Christ alone saves a person (Eph. 2:8). Baptism before a profession of faith and repentance is merely an exercise in getting wet. -DM


[1] Erwin Lutzer, Rescuing the Gospel (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker, 2016), 158.

No comments:

Post a Comment